PickRating public rankings
Sports pick rating methodology
Learn how PickRating independently captures picks, verifies results and bookmaker prices, normalizes stakes, and calculates official Points.
Independent capture and grading
PickRating tracks publicly available picks published before the event. We retain the selection and source link, and settle supported picks against an independent scores feed rather than inheriting a tipster’s claimed result or units. Picks we cannot independently settle are not presented as verified results.
Profiles show performance by sport as well as an overall record combining eligible picks across sports and shows.
Official Points
Every eligible pick uses a one-unit stake. We prefer a sufficient historical average of exact U.S. bookmaker prices available when the pick was published, matching the event, market, selection and line. An exact price captured on the source page is also valid for Points when that average is unavailable; a later sufficient exact average can replace it.
We do not invent odds or treat an assumed −110 as a posted price. Picks without a usable captured price do not earn public Points.
Wins earn profit at the verified price, losses score minus one Point, and pushes score zero. For example, a one-unit win at +150 earns +1.5 Points, not the 2.5-unit total return that includes the original stake. ROI is Points divided by verified one-unit picks, expressed as a percentage.
Public sources and historical records
We do not collect paywalled picks. When a source stops publishing free picks, its previously collected history remains available; a free-play record does not represent a paid product. VSiN’s public Pro Picks board closed on 16 September 2026.
Sportsbook comparisons
Sportsbook ratings compare observed prices and market movement, not a promise of future returns. The ratings page identifies the available observation date, sample sizes and data limitations.
Compare tipster records, review recent picks, or view sportsbook ratings.